The Culture Clash

reviewed by Jody Frederick

Jean Donaldson

1996, James & Kenneth Publishers

2140 Shattuck Ave. #2406, Berkeley, CA 94704

ISBN 1-888047-05-4

If you share your life with dogs, you owe it to yourself and your canines to pick up a copy of Jean Donaldson’s book The Culture Clash. It will give you new and amazing insight into dog behavior that will provide you with ideas of how to improve your relationship and understanding of your best friend. The book emphasizes training but it is very basic. The everyday dog owner can learn a great deal about dog behavior from this book even though they might not be interested in obedience competition.

Donaldson starts by exploding the popular “Walt Disney dog” myth that suggests that dogs are moral, extremely intelligent beings that are capable of understanding and solving complex problems. For years, we have believed that dogs think, feel and act like humans. The truth (supported by scientific research) is that although dogs are great learners, they do not think abstractly, do not have morals, do not understand language, and cannot move mentally forward and backward through time. Therefore, many of the previous training methods and approaches to understanding dog behaviors are built on misinformation.

When you bestow intelligence and morality, you bestow the responsibility that goes along with them. If the dog knows it’s wrong to destroy furniture yet deliberately and maliciously does it, remembers the wrong he did and feels guilt, it feels like he merits a punishment, doesn’t it? Well, that’s just what dogs have been getting — a lot of punishment. (page 13)

Dogs cannot understand the difference between right and wrong. What they can understand is the difference between safe and dangerous. That is, chewing the sofa while the human is away is self-rewarding with no consequences (safe) but doing the same while the human is home has negative consequences (dangerous). Dogs are also incapable of recognizing the economic value of our possessions. Everything is a potential chew toy!

Donaldson also explains the “eager-to-please” fallacy–the idea that our dogs are dying to do as we wish and furthermore know what we want of them. Again, this is based on our anthropomorphic vision of dog behavior and intelligence. Dogs learn by the immediate consequences of their actions. Dogs are self-interested. If there is something in it for them, they will do it. If there is nothing in it for them, they require motivation.

“The Dominance Panacea” is another myth that Donaldson takes apart. Ever since humans discovered pack order in wolves, dog owners have been explaining every conceivable dog-dog and human-dog interaction in terms of dominance. “Dogs misbehave or are disobedient because they haven’t been shown who’s boss.” How many times have we heard that? Donaldson believes that this viewpoint amounts to yet another opportunity for punishment-based training methods. Behind a dog that rushes through doorways first, fails to come when called, or pulls on its leash is a human who has not taught the dog what is inappropriate. In other words, we should rule out lack of training before we immediately assume the dog is planning a coup of our leadership.

Other important behaviors can be understood when you recognize that dogs are predators. Predatory behavior results in searching, stalking, rushing, chasing, biting, and dissection. Furthermore, the dog is a pack animal and is programmed to be constantly around others to survive. Separation from the group activates behaviors that help reunite with the pack These behaviors include agitation, distress vocalizations, scratching, digging and chewing.

Aggressive behavior in domestic dogs is another issue that needs to be addressed, according to the author. Biting is natural, normal dog behavior, which is why it is so prevalent. She states:

Biting and threat displays (which are simply the indication of intention to bite) are how dogs settle both minor and major disputes and defend themselves from any perceived threat they cannot or opt not to flee from. In dog culture there are no letters to the editor, slanderous gossip and backstabbing, guilty feelings, democratic institutions or litigation lawyers. There are growls, snarls, snaps and bites. (page 57)

The problem is that dogs have been domesticated into our culture which views biting as a betrayal of trust and is met with capital punishment. With these few examples, you can begin to see how very different our cultures truly are.

To say that this book has been eye-opening for me is an understatement. Donaldson’s frank and often humorous descriptions of dog behavior have challenged my beliefs and values to their very core. I highly recommend this book to anyone who’s interested in moving beyond the “Walt Disney dog” myth and seeing a dog for what it really is…and isn’t.

CG W 97

Comments are closed.

Use "ctrl+" or "ctrl-" to increase or decrease text size.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 567 other followers

Posts Calendar

April 2021


Blog Stats

  • 1,301,797 hits
%d bloggers like this: